Columbus Crew goalkeeper Nicholas Hagen (1) makes save during the U.S. Open Cup soccer final against the St. Louis CITY SC at

Louis City won the first trophy in the club's history on Wednesday after defeating Columbus Crew on penalties to lift the U.S. Columbus Crew goalkeeper Nicholas Hagen (1) makes save during the U.S. Open Cup soccer final against the St.

Louis CITY SC at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field in Columbus on Oct.